Why insurance excess South Africa policies include can catch you off guard
Here's something we see all the time: someone shops for car or home insurance, finds a great monthly premium, signs up — and then gets a nasty shock when they need to claim. The reason? They didn't check the insurance excess South Africa policies typically include.
The excess is the chunk of money you need to pay before the insurer pays the rest of your claim. And in a country where most of us are juggling rent, groceries, transport, school fees and maybe a personal loan or two, that can really mess with your budget if you're not prepared.
So let's break it down in plain language.
What is insurance excess, exactly?
Think of it this way. You've got car insurance. Someone smashes your window and steals your sound system. The repair quote comes back at R8 000. Your policy has a R1 500 excess.
That means you pay the first R1 500. The insurer covers the remaining R6 500 (assuming the claim meets all the policy rules).
The excess isn't a penalty or a fine. It's built into the policy structure. It's how insurers share the risk with you — and it also keeps premiums a bit lower, because you're covering part of every claim yourself.
Fixed rand amount vs percentage
Some policies set the excess as a flat amount — say R2 000 or R3 500. Others use a percentage of the claim or the insured value. That percentage setup can get tricky, because a 10% excess on a R500 000 home claim is R50 000. Always check which type applies to your cover.
Why this matters so much in South Africa
Let's be real. Most South African households don't have thousands of rand sitting around for emergencies. If your car gets written off or your geyser bursts and floods the house, you need that insurance payout quickly.
But if you can't come up with the excess, the claim process stalls. You might end up borrowing more money just to unlock your own insurance benefit. That's stressful — and expensive.
A low premium can look like a bargain until you realise the excess is sky-high and you can't afford to actually use the policy.
The trade-off between premium and excess
Here's the deal: insurers usually let you choose. Want a cheaper monthly premium? You'll probably get a higher excess. Prefer a lower excess so claims are easier to handle? Your monthly cost goes up.
Neither option is automatically better. It depends on your cash flow, your risk tolerance, and whether you've got a bit of savings tucked away for surprises.
- Option: Lower premium — Monthly premium: R450 — Excess per claim: R5 000 — Best for…: People with emergency savings who claim rarely
- Option: Higher premium — Monthly premium: R650 — Excess per claim: R1 500 — Best for…: People who'd struggle to find R5k in a pinch
How to compare insurance excess South Africa quotes the smart way
When you're shopping around, don't just ask "What's the monthly premium?" Ask these questions too:
That last question is the big one. If the answer is no, you might be setting yourself up for trouble down the line.
A real-world scenario
Say you're a Joburg driver earning around R15 000 a month. You find two car insurance quotes. One costs R400 a month with a R4 000 excess. The other costs R550 with a R1 200 excess.
The cheaper one saves you R150 every month — R1 800 a year. But if you have one accident, you're R2 800 worse off because of the higher excess. And if you don't have R4 000 available, you'll need to borrow it, which adds interest and fees on top.
For many people, paying a bit more monthly and keeping the excess manageable is the safer bet.
What about credit and repayment discipline?
We work with South Africans every day who are managing personal loans, vehicle finance, store accounts and more. One thing we've learned: unexpected costs are what derail even the best repayment plans.
An insurance excess you can't afford becomes another emergency expense. You might use a credit card, ask for a short-term loan, or skip other payments to cover it. That can hurt your credit record and make future borrowing more expensive.
Planning ahead — by choosing an excess you can actually handle — protects your financial stability. It's not glamorous, but it works.
Should you keep an emergency fund?
Ideally, yes. Even a small buffer of R2 000 or R3 000 can cover a typical insurance excess without forcing you into new debt. If you're building that fund from scratch, start small. Put away R200 or R300 a month until you've got enough to breathe easier.
What to do before you sign anything
Read the policy document. We know it's boring. Do it anyway. Look for the sections on excesses, exclusions and claim procedures. If something's unclear, phone the insurer and ask.
Compare at least three quotes — and compare the total cost, not just the premium. Factor in the excess, any admin fees, and whether the cover actually matches what you need.
And ask yourself honestly: if I had to claim tomorrow, could I pay this excess without borrowing more money? If the answer makes you uncomfortable, keep looking.
Frequently asked questions
What exactly is an insurance excess?
It's the amount you pay towards a claim before your insurer pays the rest. For example, if your claim is R10 000 and your excess is R1 500, you pay R1 500 and the insurer covers R8 500 (subject to policy terms).
Why do insurers use excesses at all?
Excesses help share the risk between you and the insurer, and they discourage small or frivolous claims. They also allow insurers to offer lower premiums, because you're covering part of each claim yourself.
Can I negotiate my excess?
Sometimes. Many insurers let you choose between a few excess levels, and your premium adjusts accordingly. It's worth asking what options are available.
Is it smart to pay an excess with a personal loan or credit card?
It's not ideal. Borrowing to pay an excess adds interest and fees, and it can strain your monthly budget. If you absolutely have to, make sure you understand the repayment terms and that you can afford the instalments.
Should I just pick the lowest premium I can find?
Not always. A low premium often comes with a high excess. If you can't afford that excess when you need to claim, the cheap policy ends up costing you more in the long run. Balance is key.
This article is for general informational purposes only and is not financial advice. Spring Loans is a registered South African credit provider — please speak to a qualified financial adviser or registered credit provider before making borrowing decisions.
Ready to apply?
Spring Loans is a registered South African credit provider. Visit www.springloans.co.za to check your eligibility and apply online.
.svg)
